Should I Stay or Go? Questions Before Changing Brokerages

by Mike Ferrante

Screenshot 2025-12-30 at 12.00.44 PM
Should I Stay or Go? Questions Before Changing Brokerages

It's November, and December is right around the corner. If you're a real estate agent, you know what this time of year does to you. You start thinking about next year: business plans, goals, budgets, what's working and what isn't. And for a lot of agents, a bigger question sneaks in too. Does my current situation actually meet my needs? Is it time to make a move?

I know that feeling well. For years, every time the end of the year came around, I'd sit down and ask myself, "How am I doing here?" The old Clash song pretty much says it all. Should I stay or should I go?

I just taught a new CE class for Ohio agents on this exact topic, "Teams & Brokerages: What Agents Don't Ask Until It's Too Late." Here are some of the biggest takeaways. And I'll say it right up front: this isn't only for agents thinking about leaving. Even if you're staying put, these are great conversations to have with your current broker, team leader or manager.

Start with the one thing that matters most to you

I opened the class by asking agents what matters most to them in their business. The answers were all over the place: leads, support, respect, integrity, training, coaching, mentoring, even fun events. A lot of people assume it all comes down to splits and money. For a lot of agents, it's culture.

There's no one best model. There are boutique brokerages, national brands, cloud-based brokerages, and offices where the water cooler conversations still happen. There are lead-based teams, rainmaker teams, family teams, small "SEAL" teams and mega teams. Driving through Central Ohio to visit my teammate Mike Pillow down at Apple Valley Lake, I noticed whole towns dominated by small local brokerages I had never heard of. The big brand doesn't always win.

When I was picking a college, I looked at Miami and Ohio State, then visited Heidelberg College (now Heidelberg University) out in Tiffin. It had about 1,100 students, and it just felt like home. My first week, I went to a meeting at the campus radio station. I hadn't said a word, and they asked who I was and what time slot I wanted. I said I was a freshman and didn't know anything about radio. They said, don't worry, we'll teach you. Just like that, I had Sunday nights, 9 to midnight.

For me, it was a great fit. Other people would have been miserable there. Picking a team or brokerage works the same way. The question isn't which model is best. It's which model is best for you.

Know who's actually responsible

The principal broker is at the top and is ultimately responsible for everything. Broker associates may have management duties, so you may be able to bring questions to them. But don't assume your team leader is a broker. I happen to be a broker associate, but I'm not the principal broker, and I shouldn't be making decisions on their behalf. Know the chain of command and know when to escalate.

Write down this one question: what is my deductible?

If you take one thing from this post, make it this. It's one of the questions in our free guide, too. Ask your broker or manager how much your errors and omissions deductible is, and who pays it if a claim comes in.

Around my fifth year in real estate, our company had a $10,000 deductible. We had both sides of a rental on a house in Cleveland that rented for $650 a month. Months after the tenant moved in, a lawsuit came. I'll go to my grave saying I did nothing wrong. It still cost me over $9,000, because I was on the hook for the deductible on the legal defense. My broker didn't pay it. I did.

E&O is there for claims that come out of your professional work, like a wrong date on a contract or something a client says you should have told them. But every policy has exclusions, and what's covered varies a lot from one policy to the next. Some policies give you better terms if you've met certain conditions, like completing specific training, so ask what those are.

Fair warning: if you walk up to your broker and ask about the deductible, the first thing they'll say is, "Oh my gosh, what did you do?" Tell them you didn't do anything. You just think it's something you should know. And you should, whether you're staying or going.

Independent doesn't mean unsupervised

Most of us are independent contractors, and I like it that way. The harder I work and the more families I help, the more I can earn. But a lot of agents hear "independent" and think "I can do whatever I want." That's not how it works. Your license hangs with a broker. State license law still applies. If you're a Realtor, so does the Code of Ethics. Even principal brokers answer to someone.

Advertising is where I see this the most. Ads, videos and social posts that say "Contact Mike, I've got this house for sale" with no brokerage anywhere. Yard signs where the team name is huge and you can't even tell what company it's with. In Ohio, the team advertising rule says the brokerage name has to appear with equal or greater prominence than the team name.

"Everybody does it" isn't a defense. It's like speeding. The car that flies past you doesn't get pulled over, but the moment you go over, you do. It only takes one person to screenshot your post.

Supervision matters more than ever on the phone side too. At my brokerage's national event, an attorney spent about half an hour on stage talking about the phone laws. Brokerages have paid big settlements over agents calling the wrong people the wrong way, including a $20 million settlement over unwanted listing calls. Whatever model you're in, ask how supervision, training and advertising approval actually work.

Who owns your stuff when you leave?

Remember this word: portability. Your CRM, photos, videos, website, social media accounts, reviews. Who really owns them? Can you export them and take them with you?

I learned this one the hard way. I had about 1,000 videos online. When I changed brokerages, I re-read my agreement, and by "re-read" I mean read it for the first time. I wasn't allowed to keep content online with the old branding, so I took down about 700 videos. Months later I was still finding old branding scattered around the internet. Looking back, I would have produced those videos differently, with the branding in the text instead of baked into the video itself.

Ask who gets credit for closed deals, too. Our team used to close everything under one name so we'd rank higher on places like Zillow and Google. Today we close deals in our teammates' names when it's their sale, split it when I'm working on it with them, and only put it in my name when it's just me. Neither way is wrong, but you should know the answer before you join.

Thinking about a move? Plan it quietly

Don't announce anything early. Read your independent contractor agreement. Most agents in my class admitted they hadn't read theirs, at least not since they signed it. Figure out which listings and pending contracts you have and what happens to your buyer agreements. Know whether notice is required and what that means for you once you give it.

Someone I worked with left a franchise to start her own brokerage. Years later, she told me that if she had asked the right questions, she might have made a different choice.

Above all, have a plan for your clients. They shouldn't feel the bumps when you change companies.

A quick tip: AI is great at this. Once a year, drop your agreement into ChatGPT or a similar tool, tell it how your business has changed, and ask what you should pay attention to. Take out anything confidential first, like client names or account details. It's not legal advice, but it beats never reading it.

Get Our Guide: Questions Every Agent Should Ask Before Joining a Team or Brokerage

I put together the full list of questions I walked through in class, covering compensation, leads and clients, branding, supervision, contractor status and leaving on good terms. It's free, and all I need is your name and email.

It's completely confidential. I know a lot of agents want to keep it private that they're even thinking about a move. Nobody gets a call, and nobody finds out you asked. And if you're staying put, use it as a checklist for a conversation with your current broker or team leader.

Get Our Guide here

Even if you stay, ask the questions

You don't have to be leaving to have this conversation. Sit down with your current broker, team leader or manager before the new year and say, "Here are the challenges I'm facing. How can you help me with them?" Ask what success should look like for you 12 to 24 months from now. Ask about your deductible. Bring the full question list with you. The best time to know the answers is before something goes wrong, not after.

If you want a second opinion on your situation, I'm happy to talk, and that conversation stays between us. And if you want to get better with AI in your business, join us in person at our Solon office on Wednesday, December 16, from noon to 1 for a one-hour ChatGPT CE class, with an optional hands-on workshop after. Seats are limited, so watch our Facebook events page to register.

This post is general information, not legal, tax or accounting advice. Talk to your broker, attorney or tax professional about your specific situation.

Mike Ferrante
The Mike Team at LPT Realty
www.21mike.com
Google Business Profile: https://g.page/r/CSQoYzel0Z68EAE
+1 (216) 373-7727

Mike Ferrante
Mike Ferrante

Broker Associate

+1(216) 373-7727 | mike@21mike.com

GET MORE INFORMATION

Name
Phone*
Message